1. Photo & Video
  2. Archive

How to Make a Historical Then-and-Now Picture and Animated Gif

Then-and-now pictures are more than a fun to look at to see how an area has changed, they’re also a great way to connect to our history. Here's how you can make your own.

Choose Your Area and Image

You need to give some thought to the pictures you want to represent. If the area is indistinguishable from what it used to be, then it might be an interesting discussion point, but fall a little flat in a picture that focuses on direct comparison.

Try to choose a place that still has some obvious architectural or geographical features if you can. Look for original buildings and other ‘anchors’ like fountains or the shape of the street.

Grindon HallGrindon HallGrindon Hall
Grindon Hall—around the 1920s

This is the archive image I've chosen. It's a building near to where I grew up that's changed uses many times—it's been a manor house, an infectious disease centre and most recently, a free school. The great thing about this building is that many of the original features still exist, even though the building has been extended.

Although this image wasn't dated in the local archive, it's certainly pre-1920s. I can work that out from the existing history, how it was in use and what features were still there at the time (like the lions!).

How to Make Your Original Image, Digital

You can read more about digitising your archive images in our Archival Photo Restoration course, but here are a couple of things you should be thinking about.

The best way to digitise your image is to use a scanner capable of making high-resolution copies. Clean your scanner bed before you use it, to make sure you’re not picking up any bits of dust or marks on the glass.

If you don’t have a scanner, don’t worry, it’s possible to make a good copy of your image using a digital camera. Try to take your photograph as ‘straight’ on as you can and be aware of any light reflections, strange angles or bends in your photo.

How to Take Your Contemporary Image

You know what you want to photograph, so now the key is to photograph it in a way that’s going to make the merging of the two as easy as possible for you.

Take your archive image, or a copy of it, with you. When you’re lining up your new image, try to match the distance and pay attention to the landmarks I mentioned earlier, and also things like the slope of a roof and position of windows: those will all be markers that help you match up your images later.

look for angles and featureslook for angles and featureslook for angles and features
Look for angles and features

Here, I've marked in white a few of the things I looked at when taking my contemporary image. Things like the chimney pot and the pillars still exist, so I'd try to match those up as best I can. I'm also looking at things like the angle of the roof, which should help me judge the distance and perspective.

Try and use a lens that doesn’t distort too much. Avoid anything too wide, where you might get some distortion and barrelling. You can correct that to an extent in post-production, but it’s always best to get it as close as you can in camera, first.

It might be a big ask, but try to match the lighting conditions if you can. It may be hard to tell on an old photograph, but look for shadows and where the light is hitting, and try to replicate it by shooting as close to that time as you can.

Grindon Hall contemporary Grindon Hall contemporary Grindon Hall contemporary
Grindon Hall as it is today

This is my contemporary image. Though some of the features are a little off, it's not too bad when compared to the original.

How to Merge Your Images in Adobe Photoshop

You won’t want to do too much post-production to your contemporary image, so just give it some basic colour and contrast corrections if needed.

Next, open your archive image as your bottom (or background) layer and pull your contemporary one in so it appears as a smart object. Use the Opacity slider to lower the transparency of your modern image.

transparency layertransparency layertransparency layer
Transparency layer

Now resize it to roughly match your archive photograph: Select your top image (or Select All on that layer) and then right-click, choosing Transform Selection

transform selectiontransform selectiontransform selection
Right click and hit Transform Selection

If you right-click again you'll see you're presented with some more options:

  • Scale—enlarges or reduces 
  • Rotate—turns based on a fixed point
  • Skew—slants vertically or horizontally
  • Distort—stretches
  • Perspective—applies one-point perspective
  • Warp—alters the shape
options for adjustmentoptions for adjustmentoptions for adjustment
Adjustment options

Use these tools to subtly adjust your image until it's as close to the original as possible. Don't push it too far or you'll end up with odd, stretchy looking parts! You'll probably make most use of Perspective, Skew and Scale.

This is how mine looked—it's quite close but it's never going to be perfect. You might need to crop your image to get rid of any edges.

Animate Your Images

Make sure your Timeline is visible in Photoshop. If it isn't, go to Window and tick Timeline.

make your timeline visiblemake your timeline visiblemake your timeline visible

You'll see a button that says Create Video Timeline. Press that, and you'll see both layers (your archive and contemporary images) open in the timeline.

populate your timelinepopulate your timelinepopulate your timeline

Ideally, you want your contemporary layer to start invisible and then slowly fade in. You'll need to use the options on the left to add markers to your timeline, and then adjust the opacity in your layers panel.

I've circled some parts here to help you to see what you need to adjust. The circled dots on the timeline are where I want my desired effect to start and stop. The opacity is 0% on hitting the first marker and 100% on the second, so it'll increase gradually.

Save and Export as a Looping GIF 

When you're happy you can go ahead an export as a GIF, or whatever video format works for you.

If you need a little more help with making a GIF in Photoshop, we have a more in depth tutorial you can take a look at.

You Might Also Enjoy

It's amazing to think that these two photographs are almost 100 years apart and very little has changed with the building, although I do wish it still had those gorgeous lion statues! Here are a few more tutorials to keep you in the mood for history.

Looking for something to help kick start your next project?
Envato Market has a range of items for sale to help get you started.